Thrift Stores Fishers

Vintage & Secondhand Shops Fishers, Indiana

[{'name': "Next-To-New Thrift at St. Mark's", 'address': '710 E. Buchanan St. 46168', 'city': 'Plainfield', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'plainfield', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.7034609, 'longitude': -86.3916281, 'distance': 631.7, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:58:01.476008+00:00', 'slug': 'next-to-new-thrift-at-st-marks', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13092/', 'img_alt': "Next-To-New Thrift at St. Mark's in Plainfield, Indiana", 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True, 'Article': True}, 'open_now': 'false'}, {'name': 'Goodwill Store', 'address': '2480 N. Lebanon St. 46052', 'city': 'Lebanon', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'lebanon', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 40.074774, 'longitude': -86.474836, 'distance': 631.7, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:58:27.481799+00:00', 'slug': 'goodwill-store-59', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13141/', 'img_alt': 'Goodwill Store in Lebanon, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'true'}, {'name': 'Goodwill Store', 'address': '3724 Shady Ln. 46168', 'city': 'Plainfield', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'plainfield', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.7159899, 'longitude': -86.3662656, 'distance': 633.1, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:58:00.481107+00:00', 'slug': 'goodwill-store-47', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13090/', 'img_alt': 'Goodwill Store in Plainfield, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'true'}, {'name': 'Goodwill Store', 'address': '11 E Garner Rd. 46112', 'city': 'Brownsburg', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'brownsburg', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.8655425, 'longitude': -86.3918841, 'distance': 633.4, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:57:57.883851+00:00', 'slug': 'goodwill-store-43', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13085/', 'img_alt': 'Goodwill Store in Brownsburg, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'true'}, {'name': 'Goodwill Store', 'address': '193 Avon Village Pkwy. 46123', 'city': 'Avon', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'avon', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.7666786, 'longitude': -86.3570875, 'distance': 634.1, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:57:58.429030+00:00', 'slug': 'goodwill-store-44', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13086/', 'img_alt': 'Goodwill Store in Avon, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'true'}, {'name': 'Goodwill Store', 'address': '6065 S. Main St. 46075', 'city': 'Whitestown', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'whitestown', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.9520119, 'longitude': -86.3444149, 'distance': 636.9, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:57:59.965807+00:00', 'slug': 'goodwill-store-46', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13089/', 'img_alt': 'Goodwill Store in Whitestown, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'true'}, {'name': 'Goodwill Outlet Store', 'address': '6650 W. Washington St. 46241', 'city': 'Indianapolis', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'indianapolis', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.7450007, 'longitude': -86.2760397, 'distance': 638.2, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:58:01.097586+00:00', 'slug': 'goodwill-outlet-store-5', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13091/', 'img_alt': 'Goodwill Outlet Store in Indianapolis, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'true'}, {'name': 'Goodwill Store', 'address': '6145 Crawfordsville Rd. 46224', 'city': 'Speedway', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'speedway', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.7992985, 'longitude': -86.2688575, 'distance': 639.1, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:57:58.982485+00:00', 'slug': 'goodwill-store-45', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13087/', 'img_alt': 'Goodwill Store in Speedway, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'true'}, {'name': 'Goodwill Store', 'address': '5640 W. Washington St. 46241', 'city': 'Indianapolis', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'indianapolis', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.7512222, 'longitude': -86.2567039, 'distance': 639.3, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:58:01.823112+00:00', 'slug': 'goodwill-store-48', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13093/', 'img_alt': 'Goodwill Store in Indianapolis, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'true'}, {'name': 'The Salvation Army Family Store', 'address': '5520 W. 38th St. 46254', 'city': 'Indianapolis', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'indianapolis', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.8242171, 'longitude': -86.2582037, 'distance': 640.0, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:57:59.612331+00:00', 'slug': 'the-salvation-army-family-store-17', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13088/', 'img_alt': 'The Salvation Army Family Store in Indianapolis, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'false'}, {'name': 'Greater Indy Habitat for Humanity ReStore', 'address': '4129 W. Washington St. 46241', 'city': 'Indianapolis', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'indianapolis', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.7574906, 'longitude': -86.2334512, 'distance': 640.5, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:58:03.310165+00:00', 'slug': 'greater-indy-habitat-for-humanity-restore', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13095/', 'img_alt': 'Greater Indy Habitat for Humanity ReStore in Indianapolis, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'false'}, {'name': 'Goodwill Store', 'address': '8450 N. Michigan Rd. 46268', 'city': 'Indianapolis', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'indianapolis', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.9269038, 'longitude': -86.2300872, 'distance': 642.6, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:58:02.552053+00:00', 'slug': 'goodwill-store-49', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13094/', 'img_alt': 'Goodwill Store in Indianapolis, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'true'}, {'name': 'Thrifty Threads', 'address': '1501 W. 86th St. 46260', 'city': 'Indianapolis', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'indianapolis', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.9121201, 'longitude': -86.1855677, 'distance': 644.8, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:58:03.674873+00:00', 'slug': 'thrifty-threads', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13096/', 'img_alt': 'Thrifty Threads in Indianapolis, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'false'}, {'name': 'The Salvation Army Family Store', 'address': '725 E. Washington St. 46202', 'city': 'Indianapolis', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'indianapolis', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.7660584, 'longitude': -86.1448211, 'distance': 645.3, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:58:24.009992+00:00', 'slug': 'the-salvation-army-family-store-19', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13135/', 'img_alt': 'The Salvation Army Family Store in Indianapolis, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'false'}, {'name': 'Goodwill Store', 'address': '1260 Shelby St. 46203', 'city': 'Indianapolis', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'indianapolis', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.750134, 'longitude': -86.1398956, 'distance': 645.4, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:58:24.991219+00:00', 'slug': 'goodwill-store-56', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13137/', 'img_alt': 'Goodwill Store in Indianapolis, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'FAQ': True, 'Hours': True, 'Phone': True, 'Article': True, 'Charity': True, 'Donations': True}, 'open_now': 'true'}, {'name': 'Mission 27 Resale', 'address': '132 leota St. 46202', 'city': 'Indianapolis', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'indianapolis', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.7644718, 'longitude': -86.1369797, 'distance': 645.7, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:58:24.627330+00:00', 'slug': 'mission-27-resale', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13136/', 'img_alt': 'Mission 27 Resale in Indianapolis, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'false'}, {'name': 'Good News Ministries Thrift Store', 'address': '2716 E. Washington St. 46206', 'city': 'Indianapolis', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'indianapolis', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.7684702, 'longitude': -86.1170263, 'distance': 646.8, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:58:25.643734+00:00', 'slug': 'good-news-ministries-thrift-store', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13138/', 'img_alt': 'Good News Ministries Thrift Store in Indianapolis, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'false'}, {'name': 'Goodwill Store', 'address': '1530 N. Morton St. 46131', 'city': 'Franklin', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'franklin', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.4939811, 'longitude': -86.0650557, 'distance': 647.0, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:58:17.793980+00:00', 'slug': 'goodwill-store-53', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13124/', 'img_alt': 'Goodwill Store in Franklin, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'true'}, {'name': "Lord's Cupboard", 'address': '606 Banta St. 46131', 'city': 'Franklin', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'franklin', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.4843997, 'longitude': -86.0632931, 'distance': 647.0, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:58:18.470501+00:00', 'slug': 'lords-cupboard', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13125/', 'img_alt': "Lord's Cupboard in Franklin, Indiana", 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'false'}, {'name': 'Goodwill Store', 'address': '989 N. Emerson Ave. 46143', 'city': 'Greenwood', 'state': 'Indiana', 'cityslug': 'greenwood', 'stateslug': 'indiana', 'latitude': 39.6315658, 'longitude': -86.0828097, 'distance': 647.2, 'shop_type': 'thrift-store', 'last_updated': '2025-04-29T23:58:17.060130+00:00', 'slug': 'goodwill-store-52', 'rating': 0.0, 'main_image': 'https://www.nearestdoor.com/get-image/13123/', 'img_alt': 'Goodwill Store in Greenwood, Indiana', 'shop_type_unslug': 'thrift store', 'additonal_filters': {'Hours': True, 'Phone': True}, 'open_now': 'true'}], 39.9555928, -86.0138729

Thrift Store Community News & Tips

Grand-opening scene inside a new Savers Value Village store with a red 'NOW OPEN' banner, aisles of color-sorted clothing, and signage reading 'Smart Tag AI Pricing'., thrift-store

Savers Value Village Unveils 30-Store Expansion & Smart Tag AI Pricing

North America’s largest for-profit thrift chain maps 30 new stores and debuts AI-driven price labels—see the rollout schedule, shopper perks, and sustainability stakes.

AI dashboard of Thrift Production Manager displayed on a tablet in a busy donation-sorting room, overlaid with a RetailTech Breakthrough Awards 2025 trophy badge., thrift-store

AI-Powered Thrift Production Manager Wins 2025 RetailTech Breakthrough Award

RCS’s new software slashes processing time and lifts margins for Goodwill & Salvation Army—here’s why every thrift shop should care.

CCAD fashion student adjusts an upcycled couture dress on a mannequin inside a Goodwill store, with racks of donated clothing in the background., thrift-store

Goodwill x CCAD Debuts Zero-Waste Runway Across Columbus Stores

Eighteen design students transformed thrifted textiles into avant-garde garments now on view at four Goodwill Columbus locations—see how zero-waste fashion can revive your closet.

CCAD student showcasing avant-garde outfit made from upcycled Goodwill materials., thrift-store

Goodwill & CCAD Partner to Turn Thrift Finds Into Avant-Garde Fashion

See how Goodwill Columbus students transformed donated items into runway-ready looks on display through May 5.

Exterior of Worn Again Thrift with colorful retro sign on historic brick facade., thrift-store

Worn Again Thrift Re-opens in Historic Bank Building

Beloved Bellingham vintage shop doubles its size after moving into a landmark downtown bank—discover what’s new.

Shoppers browsing clothing racks under green Earth Month banners at a Goodwill store during a 50%-off sustainability event., thrift-store

Goodwill Arizona Celebrates Earth Month with 50%-Off Sale & Sustainability Goals

Everything you need to know about Goodwill AZ’s April 21 half-price blowout, donation challenge, and new AI sorting tech.

Thrift Stores

Looking for top-rated thrift stores in Fishers, Indiana? Whether you’re a local or just visiting, we help you discover clean, spacious, and budget-friendly thrift shops. From vintage clothing to unique furniture, enjoy a fantastic shopping experience while supporting sustainable living.

What to Look for in a Thrift Store

Not all thrift stores are the same. Keep these factors in mind when choosing where to shop:

Selection: Look for a wide range of items, including clothing, home goods, and unique finds.
Quality: Inspect items for good condition—well-maintained products offer better value.
Price: Great deals are common, but watch for seasonal sales and special promotions.
Convenience: Choose a conveniently located store to save time and make visits easier.

Thrift Store Do’s and Don’ts

Do: Check for new arrivals—many stores restock frequently.
Do: Keep an open mind—you never know what hidden gems you’ll find.
Don’t: Don’t hesitate to ask for discounts on slightly damaged items.
Don’t: Don’t forget to check for signs of wear, especially on clothing and furniture.

Benefits of Shopping at Thrift Stores

Thrift stores in Fishers offer more than just great prices—they promote sustainable living and unique discoveries:

Eco-Friendly: Reduce waste and promote recycling by giving items a second life.
Unique Finds: Discover rare, vintage, and retro pieces not available in regular stores.
Save Money: Get high-quality products for a fraction of the price of new items.

Tips for Thrift Store Shoppers

Be patient—great finds often take time. Visit regularly to spot the best deals.
Inspect items carefully or try them on before purchasing to ensure quality.
Bring reusable shopping bags to reduce waste and stay organized.
Ask about store discounts or bulk purchase deals—many shops offer hidden savings.

Discover even more secondhand treasures, sustainable fashion, and vintage finds in Fishers, Indiana with NearestDoor—your trusted guide to the best thrift stores nearby.